“Do you as an Amazon director approve of this policy of sanctioning books?”

By Liesa Malik

The first post on this topic was published on August 22 (Hachette vs. Amazon--Do We All Lose?) As before...any opinions expressed here are mine as an individual and do not reflect an official stance by RMFW or its members . . .

As the battle between Hachette and Amazon continues over the pricing and distribution of ebooks, Authors United took a second swipe at the on-line giant by publicly asking individual Amazon board members to reconsider the sanctions imposed on Hachette authors.

In May, Hachette and Amazon broke away from the bargaining table and took their disagreements public. While stories about the conflict started showing up in the press, Amazon apparently took out its wrath on individual authors who happen to be represented by publishing giant, Hachette Book Group. These authors, many of whom are household names, had things like competitive pop-up ads cover their author pages, delayed shipping of books, and removal of buy buttons from some of their titles.

I sat down with author Douglas Preston (co-author of the best-selling Pendergast thriller series, as well as several fiction and non-fictions works of his own) to talk about what authors may want from Amazon.

Photo credit: Christine Preston
Photo credit: Christine Preston

"We're not taking sides in this dispute, but simply asking Amazon not to target authors," said Mr. Preston. "Basically, there is a lot on the web misrepresenting our position, so this is a good opportunity to reinforce what we're trying to say."

The quiet and thoughtful writer said he decided to take action when he noticed his sales drop by 60% to 70%. "I wrote a letter hoping twelve brave authors would sign it. I've received over one thousand responses." That's how Authors United was formed.

The letter, an open missive to Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos, asked the online retail giant to curtail the harmful practices that were hurting individual authors. The letter went viral.

In response, Amazon started Readers United, with more verbiage to debate Mr. Preston's assertions.

Then, in the week of September 14-20, Authors United decided to take the additional step of contacting each board member of Amazon. In part, the new letter reads:

"No group of authors as diverse or prominent as this has ever come together before in support of a single cause . . ."

"We are literary novelists, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalists, and poets; thriller writers and debut and midlist authors. We are science fiction and travel writers; historians and newspaper reporters; textbook authors and biographers and mystery writers. We have written many of your children's favorite stories."

"Collectively, we have sold more than a billion books. Amazon's tactics have caused us profound anguish and outrage."

Mr. Preston said, "This feels like betrayal. Amazon wants authors to put up author pages, which is mutually beneficial, but we help them sell our books by listing other authors we like, reviewing other author's books, and occasionally writing blogs for them about books we like to read. We're happy to do this because everyone benefits."

Then Mr. Preston's voice took on an edge. "To add gratuitous insult, when you go to my page and pull up one of my books, a big pop-up window emerges suggesting I might enjoy another book (not by a Hachette author) at a better price."

Mr. Preston said that he's always had warm feelings for Amazon, and is himself, a Prime Member of the on-line store. But with this conflict his feelings may be undergoing change. "They (Amazon) shouldn't block sales or inconvenience customers. I can't get my own book in less than a few weeks."

Was the second letter effective? That remains to be seen, but last weekend (September 20th) an annual secret soiree held in New Mexico for big name authors and hosted by Amazon was missing some invitations—significantly, invitations to Hachette authors or those who have publicly shown support for Authors United.

I asked Mr. Preston in August if he could see a happy ending to the dispute. "What I hope," said Mr. Preston, "is that we can create a healthy eco-system in publishing for Amazon, for Hachette, for authors to be able to support themselves and feed their families.

Side Note: Attempts to contact representatives for either Amazon or Hachette have been met with refusal and reference to public relations bulletins. While I will keep an eye on this situation, this ends my entries for the RMFW blog for a while.

Liesa Malik
at
Liesa Malik is a freelance writer & marketing consultant living in Littleton, CO, with her husband and two pets. Liesa has built on her writing interest with a long-standing membership in Rocky Mountain Fiction Writers and recently joined the board of Rocky Mountain Mystery Writers of America. She is the author of Faith on the Rocks: a Daisy Arthur Mystery. Most days you can find Liesa either at her desk or at a local ballroom dance studio. For more about Liesa, please visit her website: LiesaMalik.Wordpress.com. More about Liesa on her website.

4 thoughts on ““Do you as an Amazon director approve of this policy of sanctioning books?”

  1. Thank you for the update, Liesa. This is all so very troubling. I hope it’s resolved soon. The last thing we need is a polarization of authors and readers. Argh!

    • Hi Janet,
      Thanks for the feedback–and I agree. The sooner things are settled among the giants, the better it will be for all of the rest of us. Just hoping the settlements result in a healthy economic situation for everyone concerned. This is another question about how much is art worth? Best to you.

  2. It all makes for interesting reading, doesn’t it? Nathan Lowell provided some feedback on this post over at Google+. There’s enough controversy here to last for a long time, but it’s sort of like political ads…you’re never quite sure you have the whole story.

  3. Hi Pat,
    You’re right about not getting the whole story. We have a better chance of doing so in print than with the few sound-bites on television and YouTube, but like most controversies, there is a lot of backstory and negotiations that may effect us, but for which we have little say. Thanks for posting this subject. Wishing you well.

Leave a Reply